Skip to content

Your cookie preferences

Initial assessment

Search the site

Type at least 2 letters to search.

Article

Dental Implant Malpractice in Turkey: Faulty Treatment, Patient Rights and Compensation

Complication or faulty treatment? The burden of proof, consent forms, consumer rights, compensation and the key evidence in dental implant disputes in Turkey.

Published:

A dental mirror held in front of a blurred dental unit
On this page (9)

Harm that appears after dental implant treatment usually means a new surgical procedure, additional costs and a longer course of treatment for the patient. Legal protection is not limited to a refund of the price paid for the implant. Corrective treatment costs, loss of earnings and the consequences of harm to bodily integrity caused by faulty planning, placement or follow-up can all form part of a compensation claim. Which procedure the patient consented to, and with knowledge of which risks, is a separate question that must be examined apart from whether the treatment was medically appropriate.

For this reason, the first step in a dental implant dispute is to examine the treatment as a whole before giving the failure a name. The explanation “a complication occurred” does not answer why the risk materialised or how it was managed afterwards. Likewise, a consent document bearing the patient’s signature does not make treatment that falls short of professional standards lawful. Liability is assessed on the basis of the findings before treatment, the treatment records, the content of the information given and the steps taken in response to the patient’s complaints.

What is dental implant malpractice?

Malpractice generally means harm suffered by a patient because a healthcare service was not provided in line with the required professional standards. In implant treatment, the assessment is not limited to the surgical procedure. The examination and planning before treatment, the placement itself, the prosthetic stage and the follow-up after treatment can all matter together.

The legal review focuses on the following questions:

  • Were the patient’s existing condition and suitability for treatment adequately assessed?
  • Were the chosen method and its application in line with professional standards?
  • Were the risks of the procedure and the alternatives explained to the patient?
  • Were complaints after the procedure answered in good time and in the necessary way?
  • Is there a causal link between the harm claimed and the breach of duty?

The answers to these questions are determined separately for each patient and each treatment. Article 49 of the Turkish Code of Obligations is the basis of liability in tort, while Article 112 of the same Code is important for liability arising from breach of contract.

Legal basis: Turkish Code of Obligations, Articles 49 and 112.

How is a complication distinguished from faulty treatment?

Medical procedures carry risks. The materialisation of a risk does not in itself mean that the treatment was faulty. However, calling an adverse outcome a “complication” does not end the legal review either.

Whether the risk was foreseen, whether the measures needed to reduce it were taken, whether the patient was informed and whether the right steps were taken once the risk materialised are each assessed separately. Even if the initial treatment was appropriate, negligence in following up a problem that arose later can give rise to liability of its own.

For example, where implant loss, infection or a change in sensation is alleged, the cause of the outcome and the approach taken during the process are investigated as well as the nature of the outcome. Without a medical assessment of the specific case, none of these outcomes can be said with certainty to be malpractice.

Legal basis: Turkish Code of Obligations, Articles 49 and 112; Code of Civil Procedure, Article 266.

Does the patient carry the entire burden of proof alone?

In a contractual compensation claim, it is important for the patient to set out the conduct in breach of the obligation, the harm and the causal link between them. However, the rule in Article 112 of the Turkish Code of Obligations on proof of fault should not be overlooked: “If an obligation is not performed at all or is not performed properly, the obligor must compensate the obligee for the resulting loss unless it proves that no fault whatsoever can be attributed to it” (unofficial translation). In contractual liability, therefore, the burden of proving the absence of fault lies with the obligor. This allocation cannot be reversed by expecting the patient to master every technical detail of the treatment and every record held by the healthcare provider from the outset.

Legal basis: Turkish Code of Obligations, Article 112.

A consent form does not mean that the patient accepted faulty treatment or waived the right to compensation. What the patient consents to is the medical procedure accepted after adequate information, not treatment that breaches the duty of professional care. Article 115 of the Turkish Code of Obligations also declares absolutely void any agreement made in advance excluding liability for slight fault in professions that require a licence. A general exclusion of liability inserted in a consent document therefore cannot remove the patient’s rights against faulty treatment.

Article 70 of Law No. 1219 on the Practice of Medicine and Its Branches requires the patient’s prior consent for procedures performed by dentists. Articles 15, 18 and 26 of the Patient Rights Regulation also set rules on the scope and method of informing the patient and on the consent form.

In implant treatment, it is important that the information covers the method to be used, the alternatives, the expected benefits, the possible risks and the recommendations the patient must follow during treatment. In a dispute, the content of the form, its connection to the specific procedure and how the information was given are examined as well as whether a form exists. We discuss the information process for patients coming from abroad in our article Informed consent and the legal rights of foreign patients in Turkey.

Legal basis: Turkish Code of Obligations, Article 115; Law No. 1219, Article 70; Patient Rights Regulation, Articles 15, 18 and 26.

Which pecuniary and non-pecuniary damages can be claimed?

The scope of compensation depends on the harm proven and its connection to the conduct giving rise to liability. In cases of bodily harm, Article 54 of the Turkish Code of Obligations covers in particular treatment costs, loss of earnings and losses arising from reduced or lost capacity to work.

Depending on the circumstances of the case, the costs of necessary corrective treatment, the costs of further procedures and loss of income for the period in which the patient could not work may be claimed. Each cost must nevertheless be documented: whether it was necessary, its amount and its connection to the earlier treatment. The same loss cannot be compensated more than once under different headings.

Where bodily integrity has been harmed, non-pecuniary damages may also be claimed under Article 56 of the Turkish Code of Obligations. Non-pecuniary damages are not an automatic payment; the circumstances of the case, the physical and psychological effects suffered and the severity of the harm are taken into account.

Legal basis: Turkish Code of Obligations, Articles 54 and 56.

Do consumer rights apply to treatment at a private clinic?

Receiving a service from a private dentist or a private healthcare provider for one’s own health needs can, where the conditions are met, be a consumer transaction. In that case the defective service provisions of Consumer Protection Law No. 6502 are also considered.

Article 13 of the Law treats a service that does not have the features agreed or objectively expected as a defective service. Article 15 of the same Law provides, depending on the conditions, for the rights to have the service performed again, to free repair of the work resulting from the service, to a price reduction or to withdraw from the contract. Compensation under the Turkish Code of Obligations may also be claimed alongside the chosen right.

However, when claims such as a refund of the price and the cost of new treatment are brought together, double compensation must be avoided. The nature of the medical procedure and whether the relevant provision applies must also be examined separately in each case.

For disputes to be brought before the consumer court, mediation is a precondition to filing a lawsuit, subject to the statutory exceptions. Whether the consumer arbitration committee has jurisdiction depends on the monetary threshold on the date of application and the nature of the claim. For treatment at public healthcare institutions, the competent court system and the application procedure are different.

Legal basis: Law No. 6502, Articles 3, 13, 15, 68, 73 and 73/A.

Which evidence matters in a dental implant dispute?

A sound legal assessment requires the treatment process to be documented. The following records are particularly important:

  • The treatment plan, contract, price quote and payment documents.
  • Imaging and examination records from before and after treatment.
  • The medical records, procedure notes and implant details.
  • Information documents and consent forms.
  • Check-up records, prescriptions and correspondence between the parties.
  • Records of later treatment and cost documents.
  • If loss of income is claimed, documents showing it.

Recording the existing condition before any new procedure is useful for later review, but necessary treatment should not be delayed for the purpose of gathering evidence. Where needed, applying to the court for the preservation of evidence can also be considered.

For example, if removal of the problematic implant or replacement of the prosthesis is planned, it becomes important to document the condition before treatment with imaging and examination records. Under Article 400 of the Code of Civil Procedure, if there is a risk that evidence will be lost or that presenting it later will become significantly more difficult, the preservation of evidence can be requested even before a lawsuit is filed, provided there is a legal interest. In this way, the existing condition at the centre of the dispute can be preserved through an expert examination while necessary treatment continues.

Medical questions such as the position of the implant, the technique used and the cause of the harm require medical expertise. In a court-appointed expert examination under Article 266 of the Code of Civil Procedure, it is important that the patient’s specific complaints are answered. The examination should cover the assessment before treatment, the surgical procedure, the prosthetic stage and the follow-up, and explain with medical reasons why the adverse outcome occurred. Rather than settling for an unexplained label such as “it is a complication”, it should establish whether the necessary care was taken to prevent and manage the risk. The final decision on legal liability belongs to the court.

Legal basis: Code of Civil Procedure, Articles 266 and 400.

Conclusion

A patient harmed during dental implant treatment does not have to accept the problem without explanation or give up their rights because of a signed consent form. Effective legal protection depends on preserving the treatment records, examining the treatment and the information process separately, correctly identifying those responsible and setting out every head of loss in full. Questioning the cause of failed treatment, obtaining the necessary corrective treatment and, where the conditions are met, seeking compensation for pecuniary and non-pecuniary harm are what patient rights mean in practice.

Our work in dental implant disputes is described on our dental implant malpractice page, and questions frequently asked by patients living abroad are covered in our article What should you do if the dental treatment you received in Turkey was unsuccessful? If you would like your case assessed, you can fill in the initial assessment form or write to us.

Legislation

  • Turkish Code of Obligations No. 6098 (Official Gazette, 4 February 2011, No. 27836): Articles 49, 54, 56, 112 and 115.
  • Code of Civil Procedure No. 6100 (Official Gazette, 4 February 2011, No. 27836): Articles 266 and 400.
  • Consumer Protection Law No. 6502 (Official Gazette, 28 November 2013, No. 28835): Articles 3, 13, 15, 68, 73 and 73/A.
  • Law No. 1219 on the Practice of Medicine and Its Branches (Official Gazette, 14 April 1928, No. 863): Article 70.
  • Patient Rights Regulation (Official Gazette, 1 August 1998, No. 23420): Articles 15, 18 and 26; these articles took their current form through the amendment published in the Official Gazette of 8 May 2014, No. 28994.

Article references follow the current texts of the laws and regulations on mevzuat.gov.tr (November 2026).


This article is for general legal information. It is not a medical assessment of whether there was fault in a particular treatment, nor a legal opinion on a specific dispute. The available routes and time limits must be examined separately according to the circumstances of each case.

Recent publications

All publications